There is a simple rule for any player who has already been booked and is arguing with the referee. Stop talking. Lucas Paqueta did not stop talking, and against Liverpool it cost West Ham a man.
The sequence in the clip is short and brutal. Paqueta is already on a yellow card. A decision goes against him, he goes straight at the referee, and he keeps going. The referee has seen enough, produces a second yellow for dissent, and Paqueta is sent off. West Ham, already struggling in a 2-0 defeat, finish the match with ten men against one of the best sides in the country.
I want to look properly at why a player in his position behaves like that, because the answer is not as simple as bad temper.
What the Clip Shows
Start with the basic facts of the moment. Paqueta has a yellow card against his name. Every player in the Premier League knows what that means: one more booking and you are gone. A player on a yellow is supposed to become more careful, shorter in his protests, quicker to walk away from an argument. He is meant to treat the referee like a man holding a loaded gun.
Paqueta does the opposite. He argues, he carries on arguing, and the referee, Darren England, shows him the second yellow for dissent. Sky Sports reported that he had to be pulled away by team-mates and even by his compatriot Alisson, who plays for Liverpool, and that he kept going regardless.
Watch here:
The Context That Makes It Worse
This was not a one off. Paqueta came into that game having only just served a one match suspension for picking up an accumulation of five yellow cards in the season. So he knew exactly how close to the edge he was. A player returning from a ban has one clear task, which is to prove he has learned from it.
Instead he was sent off for dissent in his first match back. In a season where West Ham were already fighting for results, that kind of discipline problem from one of their most talented players is a serious cost. A creative midfielder who spends his afternoons arguing with the referee is of no use to a team that needs him on the pitch.
The Two Years That Changed How He Plays
The reason this clip draws such strong reactions goes back to what Paqueta went through before it. In August 2023 the FA began investigating suspicious betting patterns on yellow cards in West Ham matches. The allegation was that Paqueta had deliberately got himself booked so that other people could profit from bets. He was charged in May 2024 over four matches, against Leicester, Aston Villa, Leeds and Bournemouth, with a potential lifetime ban hanging over him.
His proposed move to Manchester City collapsed when the investigation came to light. He spent almost two years playing under a cloud, and in May 2025 he burst into tears after being booked against Tottenham, with his wife saying the family had been living a nightmare. In July 2025 an independent Regulatory Commission cleared him of all four betting charges, ruling them not proven. He had denied them from the first day.
That is the backdrop to every yellow card he now receives. When you are the one player in the league whose bookings were once scrutinised for evidence of fixing, the sensible reaction is to be the most disciplined man on the pitch. Every needless yellow gives the doubters another reason to talk, and getting sent off for arguing hands them an entire week’s worth.
Why I Have Sympathy and Why It Runs Out
I understand where the temper comes from. A player who has spent two years fighting for his name will have a very short fuse when he feels a decision has been made against him unfairly. After the Liverpool red card, Paqueta apologised publicly to his team-mates and supporters for leaving West Ham short, but he also criticised the FA, saying he had not been given proper psychological support through the ordeal. I think that is a fair point to make. Nobody comes out of a case like that unchanged.
But sympathy has limits, and this clip is where mine runs out. Dissent is the most avoidable card in football. It requires no tackle, no mistimed challenge, no heat of the moment contact. It is a decision to keep talking when everybody around you, including your own team-mates, is telling you to walk away. Paqueta was already on a yellow. The referee was never going to back down. The only person who could stop the situation was Paqueta himself, and he chose not to.
What West Ham Need From Him
West Ham have a player capable of controlling a game from midfield, with the technical quality that took him to the verge of a Manchester City move. They need that player, week after week, and not one who spends ninety minutes looking for a fight with the match official.
The answer is not complicated, even if it is hard. The fight with the FA is over. He won the part of it that mattered. The best thing he can do now for himself and for the club is to let referees make their decisions, accept that some of them will be wrong, and put his energy into the football. A player cleared of the worst accusation in the sport should be the last one who wants to give anyone another reason to talk about his bookings.
